Frequently asked questions

Understand the result before you use it.

Short answers to the most common questions about W-2 vs 1099 compensation, contractor break-even rates, tax estimates and the scope of Analyze My Income.

W-2 vs 1099 comparisons

What does the W-2 vs 1099 calculator actually compare?

It estimates the annual take-home value of the W-2 salary and the current 1099 offer under the supported model, then shows which side is higher and calculates the contractor gross needed to reach the W-2 take-home target.

What is the 1099 break-even amount?

It is the lowest modeled annual 1099 gross that reaches approximately the same take-home as the W-2 side under the inputs you supplied. It is a financial reference point, not automatically the rate you should accept.

Should I simply add 20% or 30% to my W-2 salary?

A fixed markup can be useful for a rough screen, but it ignores state tax, business expenses, self-funded health insurance and realistic billable hours. Analyze My Income calculates a scenario-specific break-even instead.

Why can the same salary produce a different 1099 target for two people?

Different states, expenses, health-insurance costs and billable-hour assumptions can materially change the contractor gross needed to reach the same modeled take-home.

Does break-even include lost W-2 benefits?

The simple comparison focuses on modeled take-home. The optional advanced comparison can add supported items such as bonus, employer health contribution, retirement match, unpaid time and a user-selected contract-risk margin.

1099 and self-employment taxes

Is self-employment tax just 15.3% of gross 1099 revenue?

No. The supported Schedule SE-style calculation is based on net earnings from self-employment after business expenses and uses the applicable Social Security and Medicare framework.

Why is the suggested tax set-aside not always 30%?

The set-aside estimate is based on the modeled taxes still to fund using your inputs. A universal percentage can be too high or too low depending on income, deductions, state tax and withholding.

Can I add W-2 income to the 1099 tax calculator?

Yes. The optional W-2 section allows supported wages and withholding to be included when estimating the broader tax picture.

Does Analyze My Income calculate quarterly tax payments?

Yes. The quarterly planner estimates a next federal payment under the supported 2026 planning model and can use prior-year tax and AGI for the general safe-harbor path.

Does the quarterly planner cover every IRS underpayment exception?

No. It does not reproduce every Form 2210 exception or every annualized-income scenario. Uneven income and special taxpayer situations can require a different calculation.

Accuracy, methodology and coverage

What tax year does the site use?

The current production model is built for tax year 2026.

Does the model cover all 50 states?

The production state layer contains all 50 states for the supported resident individual-income-tax comparison. Local city, county and other special taxes are not generally part of the standard result.

Where do the tax assumptions come from?

Federal parameters are checked against IRS and Social Security Administration material. State parameters are checked against official state tax authorities, forms, instructions, statutes or other authoritative state publications. The methodology page documents the source hierarchy and supported formulas.

Is the result the same as a filed tax return?

No. A filed return can include credits, itemized deductions, spouse income, investment income, multiple businesses, retirement contributions, local taxes, entity elections and other facts outside the standard model.

Is this tax, legal or accounting advice?

No. Analyze My Income provides planning estimates and educational information. It does not provide individualized professional advice or determine whether a worker is legally an employee or independent contractor.

About Analyze My Income

Why was Analyze My Income created?

It was created around a practical compensation question: how much should a 1099 opportunity pay to be financially comparable to a W-2 job? The project avoids treating gross salary and contractor revenue as directly equivalent.

Who is the site for?

It is designed for U.S. professionals, freelancers and independent contractors comparing employment offers, converting a salary to a contractor rate or planning self-employment taxes.

Is the site free?

The current calculators are free to use and do not require an account to run the standard tools.

Does Analyze My Income claim CPA or tax-professional review?

No. The project does not claim professional review, certification or endorsement unless such a relationship can be specifically identified and verified. The public methodology focuses on sources, formulas, assumptions and test coverage.